Editor's Review

2017 10 Best Pet Insurance

Advertising Disclosure: This website has partnered with an insurance company who represents most brands listed below and we receive compensation if you choose to purchase by clicking our links.

This ranking is based on a thorough analysis of the Pet Insurance industry as well as hundreds of real online reviews. Trupanion was not included at their request.

Rank Website At a Glance Link
trophy #1 icon

healthypaws logo

Read Review

  • Healthy Paws is #1 Ranked Pet Insurance Company 4 years running
  • Highest Customer Satisfaction
  • Best Online Reviews
  • Unlimited benefits and no claim caps
  • Trusted by thousands of pet parents
Visit Site
trophy #1 icon

Read Review

  • Petplan offers a comprehensive policy with many choices
  • Customize reimbursement level, dedictible & choose any vet
  • Highly rated customer service 24/7
  • Paperless claims via their mobile app
  • 10% online discount & free Barkbox offer
Visit Site

embrace logo

Read Review

  • Embrace allows you to choose any vet
  • Offers strong illness & Accident coverage
  • Optional wellness plan is appealing for covering spay/neutering
  • Very Consistent and Affordable Premiums over time
Visit Site

Nationwide logo

Read Review

  • New Whole Pet + Wellness policy from Nationwide Strongly Worth Considering!
  • 250 Annual Deductible with no claim caps
  • Most negative reviews online are associted with their old plans
isit Site

petfirst logo

Read Review

  • Petfrist is A+ Rated with BBB
  • No exam is required before getting coverage
  • There is a short waiting period
Visit Site

Petsbest logo

Read Review

  • Pets Best Pet Insurance
  • Drag and drop website builder solution
  • Moneyback guarantee
Visit Site

petpartners logo

Read Review

  • Pet Partners is a A+ BBB rated company affiliated with AKC
  • Some coverage limitations for some conditions
  • Lower annual deductible of $100 but has a $10k payout limit, and lower online reviews.
  • Reputable company but not the best we've found
Visit Site

aspca logo

Read Review

  • ASPCA Pet Insurance is partnered with Hartville Pet Insurance Group
  • They offer up to 90% reimbursement, lower deductibles and vet of your choice
  • Online reviews are hit and miss
Visit Site

petpremium logo

Read Review

  • Basically offers the same policies as PetPremium under another brand
  • $3000 payout limit unless you choose their top two policies
  • Overall customer reviews are positive
Visit Site

banfield logo

Read Review

  • Banfield Wellness Plans - Worth mentioning but not traditional pet insurance.
  • Includes preventative treatments designed to optimize your pet's health
  • Plan does not cover medical expensesbanfiel
Visit Site